eng 108write a summary and critique of the reading online courses are cost effective but detrimental to learning the article is retrieved and adapted from https psmag com education online courses are cost effective but detrimental to learning rese

Write a summary and critique of the reading Online courses are cost-effective but detrimental to learning

(the article is retrieved and adapted from https://psmag.com/education/online-courses-are-cost-effective-but-detrimental-to-learning-researchers-find (链接到外部网站。)see the full article including the hyperlinks here (链接到外部网站。))

The first part of the paper will be a summary of the article, written in your own words (200-250 words).

The second part of the paper will be your critique of the reading (250-300 words). In this part answer the following questions: Are the arguments convincing? What particular arguments are convincing? How and why or why not? What makes the arguments convincing/ not convincing? What are the strengths, weaknesses? Why? What evidence does the author use (facts, statistics, experts’ opinions, personal examples, etc)? Is this evidence effective/ convincing and why? What is the strongest argument? What is the weakest argument? Why?

Important: watch the slides Critical summary (for accompanying audio, download the slides) and read Critical summary format.

Consider making an online appointment at the Writing Center here. (链接到外部网站。)

(For more details, please refer to the types of evidence used in the argumentative essays discussed during Week 9)

Guidelines:

  • Length: 200-250 words for the summary and 250 -300 words for your critique. Total is about 450-550 words
  • Formatting: 1” margins, Times New Roman 12 pt. font, double-spacing throughout, except single space the header (see formatting requirements)
  • File name: Your first name + Summary.docx
  • In your intro paragraph, mention the article’s title and the author’s name.
  • Do not number or use bullets for your points; write the summary in paragraphs, arranged by subtopics that fit together logically.
  • Focus on the main points. Do not include a lot of specific details.
  • Make sure to paraphrase (use your own words). You may change the sentence structures and the order of ideas, and use synonyms to convey the meaning.
  • No quotations
  • In the critique, prove your ideas by relevant supporting evidence from the reading
  • Include a reference page in APA
  • See the Critical summary format.

Evaluation:

Content 20 points

Has an appropriate title

Includes the main points/ subpoints

Fair representation and understanding of the article

Objective summary

Critique answers the required questions

Critique relates to the article

Relevant supporting evidence

Organization 20 points

Overall organization

Strong thesis in the summary

Strong thesis in the response

Paragraphs unity

Transitions

Strong and effective conclusion

Grammar and vocabulary 15 points

Command of sentence structure

Grammatical error avoidance

Use of complex structures

Appropriate word choice

Documentation 10 points

In-text citations

Reference page

Formatting 5 points

Spelling, punctuation, capitalization 5 points